Ready for Adoption?
Adoption Network Law Center
Adoption Network Law Center
Want to Adopt? Click here.
Click here to be helped in California!
Adoption Network Law Center
Pregnant? Click here.
Adoption Network Law Center
Transracial/Transcultural Adoption Blog

04/26/07

International Adoption- Huge life changes

Posted by : Erin H in Transracial/Transcultural Adoption Blog at 06:48 am , 779 words, 338 views  
Categories: Articles, International
In my last two posts, I have written about two articles courtesy of the Salt Lake Tribune on international and transracial adoption. The first article discussed a variety of topics related to international adoption, including the “search for identity” by adopted children, and the second article was written by an adult adoptee from India who shared her feelings on not “belonging” in either the U.S. or in India.

The article I am going to write about today is from the same series, and is titled, “Transition to a New World.” This article is about Governor Jon and Mary Kaye Huntsman from Utah, and their adoption of a little girl from India and how she has adjusted during her first three months home. I briefly wrote about their adoption here. As we know, bringing a child from an orphanage in another country into a typical American home can be quite overwhelming and involves huge changes for that child. There is definitely an adjustment period for the child, as well as the family.

The Huntsman family has a daughter that was adopted from China and they have five biological children as well. The article discusses why they decided to adopt and the criticism they have faced for choosing to adopt internationally instead of domestically. I have written about this before, but I just don’t get why people seem to think they should have a say in how others should create their families. I also don’t understand the mentality that a child in need in the U.S. is more deserving of being adopted than a child in need any where else in the world. I think every family has to find and choose the adoption program that is right for their family and situation, and unless someone is going to help pay for it, they don’t get a vote. :)

The article discusses how the Huntsman family hopes to help their children come to terms with their past, how they feel about their birth mothers, the importance of their birth cultures and the ways in which they try to help the girls feel connected to their cultures and create a truly multinational family. These are issues relevant to all transracial adoptive families.

I do have to admit that I cringed a few times, reading quotes in the article. I think this one bugged me the most…

"Our policy from the very beginning has been to be very open in discussions with Gracie, as we will be with Asha, about her circumstances and where she's come from and how lucky she is to be here," Jon Huntsman Jr. says.

SPONSOR
  Adopt in California


While it is easy to see how people look at a child that was an orphan, living in poverty, alone in the world…and now is living a privileged life in America in a loving family, as being “lucky”, that is not the message we are supposed to be sending our children.

Adoption is not a rescue mission and it is not charity work. Is Belane lucky that instead of living in a run down orphanage that she lives here and has a loving family and four million pink toys and a closet full of girlie clothes, and of course, access to top-notch medical care and life-saving medications? Sure. BUT, we are even luckier that we have been given this little girl…this perfect little princess…to love and care for…to get kisses and giggles and hugs and all of the blessings and joys that a child brings. Ethiopia gave us a child...one of their most precious resources.

So yes, she's lucky. But so are we. We’re equally blessed to be together.

I would never harp on her that she is “so lucky” to be here, because that sends a message of indebtedness. Just like a marriage would not be healthy if one spouse was always telling the other how “lucky” he was that they were together, adopted children shouldn’t be made to feel that they owe something because of their place in the family.

That quote is the kind of thing that adoptive parents hate to hear.

But, (off my soapbox now), all in all, it was a good article. I did really like the end, where they mentioned that despite the struggles the Huntsman girls might face because of being internationally adopted, that they would have the love, support and understanding of each other. I often feel that way when I look at my kids…that having other transracially adopted siblings is going to be a blessing in their lives as they get older.

Give it a read...let me know what you think.

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: jennmomtothree [Member] Email
OK. What I'm about to write may not be popular, and it might not come out just right. Please bear with me.

For me, an adoptive mother of 1 multiracial and 2 African American chidren, I think there's only one reason I am ever concerned about people who adopt internationally: The statement those families are making about children of color in our own country.

I certainly agree that every family has 100% latitude in making their own choice about what adoption program is right for them. There is no question about that. Only they can know where God is leading them...and the reasons for their decisions.

But I personally become uncomfortable when people will ONLY consider adopting internationally, because sometimes it feels as though something is "wrong" with the available chidren in the United States. All children deserve loving homes, and I want them to have them.

I'm ashamed that our longest adoption wait, from contact with an agency to the arrival of our newborn children and homestudy/update in between, has been three months. Why aren't families banging down the doors of these agencies for such wonderful children?

I feel uncomfortable when I'm asked where my children were born, and I share that they were born right here in the Deep South of the United States. As if it might have been better if we had brought them to our homes from another place.

Especially when so many families seem to want the experience of parenting a newborn, it's hard for me to understand why more families don't turn to transracial domestic adoption. And yet, I honor families' rights to make their own decisions about what will be best for them.

I don't know. I certainly hope what I've written isn't offensive...but it's a struggle I face, and I can't imagine I'm the only one.
PermalinkPermalink 04/26/07 @ 08:42
Comment from: haze [Member] Email · http://forneko.blogspot.com
Being a black adoptive mom-to-be to a baby girl from Ethiopia, I can't really speak to the transracial aspect of international adoption. But the 'charity case' dilemma is something I have been thinking about a lot lately.

In fact, my recents blog posts have been about this very topic (http://forneko.blogspot.com/2007/04/not-charity-case.html) and also how I came to choose to adopt internationally. It is difficult to hear people say 'oh, she'll be so lucky to be adopted by you.' But I don't want my daughter seen as a charity case - the often shown 'sad orphan' depicted in the photos and on the charity sites for AIDS orphans. And yet, the reality is, this will be part of who she is.

I also cringed when I read Barrett's article and that statement about Asha being so lucky to be in N. America. As I stated in my blog, where's the luck in losing your birth parent, your biological family, your home land??

I'm sure the Huntsmans don't mean to imply she is lucky to have suffered such losses - but I'm annoyed that they, in their public positions, make such silly and damaging statements.
PermalinkPermalink 04/26/07 @ 15:59
Comment from: Stefanie [Member] Email
That quote really made me cringe, too. The "luck" bit really got to me, I thought that in the context, "where she has come from" sounded rather derogatory towards the girls' birth countries. I'm sure the family didn't mean these things to come across like that, but I get irritated because I feel that if they took the time to spend twenty minutes on a blog like this, or on other internet sites, they might realise how their remarks sound, and reconsider or rephrase them before their children hear them!
Then again, it's perfectly possible that this was not a direct quote, and simply the product of our manipulative media... Sandra on the international adoption blog has highlighted the media's penchant for this, recently.
~Stefanie
PermalinkPermalink 04/27/07 @ 15:00
Comment from: Chromesthesia [Member] Email
I'm going to go out on a limb and say that instead of people criticising people about their personal adoption decisions, they really need to focus on reforming the foster care system completely.
There's got to be some way to push for that. Some way to rally the attention of politicians, religious leaders, social workers, therapists, all sorts of people who may disagree wtih each other, but basically care about children.
It makes no sense that to this day children are still being bounced from one foster home to the next after one failed reunion effort after another.
This sort of thing leads to attachment issues, issues of trust and so many other things that make it hard for potential adoptive parents to handle.
It's not as if adopting overseas is without simular risks. The nest step would be figuring out what to do about orphanage conditions in other countries, and how those could be improved, but I'm going insane because I can't really think of anything more important than improving things for millions of abused children!
Instead of folks going on and on about XYZ adopting from country ABC, they really need to find a way to pull some strings to make the system run smoother to make things easier and better for these children, many of whom have already endured abuse and just need trusting and loving parents help to put them on the path to healing...
Perhaps i do not understand enough of the situation, but what little I know makes me positively insane.
Also, there needs to be less negativity and less attacking of people. It doesn't do a bit of good. Ultimately people want to start a family, raise children, share their life with a child, so why look down on them for that? Why try to feel superior? It doesn't do a bit of good. Instead more of an effort should be made to educate people in a compassionate way.
PermalinkPermalink 04/27/07 @ 20:56
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

Adopt Help Adopt Help Adopt Help

Misc

Subscribe to Transracial/Transcultural Adoption Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • Guest Users: 193