Adoption Network Law Center Adoption Network Law Center
Click Here to be helped in California!
Adoption Network Law Center
Adoption Network Law Center
Pregnant? Click Here
Adoption Network Law Center
Transracial/Transcultural Adoption Blog

10/17/07

Poverty, international adoption and relinquishment

Posted by : Erin H in Transracial/Transcultural Adoption Blog at 12:20 pm , 579 words, 209 views  
Categories: Ethical Issues
In my last post I started writing about "real orphans" and how I believe that all children who have been orphaned, whether by death or relinquishment, are deserving of being adopted.

However, there are additional issues to consider when children are being relinquished for international adoption in countries that are suffering from poverty, illness, famine, lack of resources and other challenges.

In the United States it can not even be said that no birth parents relinquish their babies because of external pressure and coercion. Unfortunately, this still occurs. And if coercion still occurs in a country where pregnant women have many resources and options even under very difficult circumstances, you can be sure that in countries without any support or resources for pregnant women, that coercion occurs.

It is also important to remember that when you are looking at a typical international adoption in which a child is being relinquished, you have a family often suffering from extreme poverty (and often also illness), a child (or children), a family who desperately wants a child or children, quite a few middlemen, and a large amount of money. When you take a step back and look at it that way, it is not hard to see how easily the situation can be taken advantage of.

SPONSOR
  Adopt in California

While I know that there are many children who were truly relinquished by their first families because they were unable to care for them and wanted their children to have a better life, I also know that in some cases (in many different countries and programs), there has been external pressure to encourage relinquishment.

So while on one hand it is important to remember that it is very true that there are many parents in other countries who truly choose adoption for their children because it is their best option for whatever reason, it is also important to remember how easily the situation can be taken advantage of. Adoptive parents need to be aware of the risks.

I cannot imagine a more heart-breaking scenario as a mom to have a child that is now "mine" but knowing that that child's first mother had been pressured into giving up the child she loves, and possibly could have continued to parent her child with a little bit of encouragement or support.

I also know of several adoptive families who brought home older children who were under the impression that their first families still wanted them and were expecting them to come back home from the orphanage, and claimed that their first families did not know they were being adopted. Under those circumstances, getting the new children to bond to their adoptive family is extremely, extremely difficult.

So what is an adoptive family to do? DO YOUR RESEARCH. Don't be afraid to ask the difficult questions. I know way too many adoptive parents who shy away from confrontation or asking questions to their agency. Every adoptive parent has the right to know how their child came to be orphaned, how the agency comes into guardianship of the children they are placing, etc.

Also, if your child's birth parents are still alive, meet with them if at all possible. With our children who have birth parents and family members who are still alive, meeting with them and talking with them reassured us that adoption was truly what they wanted for their children and was in the children's best interest. That is a peace of mind that every adoptive parent deserves.

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Lisa [Member] Email · http://guatemala.adoptionblogs.com
You brought up some good points Erin. In a perfect world, children would not die of starvation on a regular basis, would 50% of the ones that live, be stunted in growth by the time they are five (Guatemalan stats).

In a perfect world there would be no corruption anywhere, not just in adoption.

As the Guatemalan blogger I am constantly defending ethical Guatemalan adoptions, and I'll never stop doing this, as exhausting as its gets. Why not? Because I don't want the "babies thrown out with the bath water."

Lies, exaggerations, and sensationalized reports are a daily matter on this subject.

Are there serious problems in Guatemalan adoptions? Yes. Isn't adoption in and of itself problematic at best? Yes. Does that ever justify committing children to lives without a family at best, or suffering from malnutrition, disease and slow death at worst? Absolutely not.

All of us who have adopted from Guatemala support changes that will monitor the adoption system better. There have been several excellent proposals put out there,but rejected by UNICEF and even the US DOS because of ignorance and politics. Guatemala will do what it is told by the "big boys."

Closing the door permanantly in countries like Guatemala with no in place social welfare programs, not one state funded orphange, and a sordid record of racism, femicide and neglect of indigenous children is a crime in my opinion.

And once again, and this can't be said enough, the children are victims.

Adoption of any kind is complex and requires intelligent, CARING, calm people to sit down and work out the logistics. This takes time and a pressure free atmosphere. Guatemala needs this; the children deserve it.
No, unfortunately it will never be perfect - nothing is - but at least hopefully it will be the best that it can be.

Lisa S. http://guatemala.adoptionblogs.com/
PermalinkPermalink 10/17/07 @ 13:58
Comment from: motherslove [Member] Email
I gave 2 boys up for adoption due to the inability to financially take care of them. I was afraid. My husband and I had seperated and I didnt think I could possibly raise 4 boys on my own. I still have 2 of the boys. They arethe older of the 4. The woman that adopted them promised updates and pics on the boys but i never recieved any. Now my older 2 are experiencing PTSD. Post traumatic stress disorders. What do I do? The adoption agency cant find them...Im afraid they may be in the foster system. I need to know they are ok, so do my other children. Does any one have any advice?
PermalinkPermalink 10/17/07 @ 14:14
Comment from: Erin H [Member] Email · http://transracial.adoptionblogs.com/
Lisa,
I hope you know that I COMPLETELY agree with you 100%...

Like I said, I believe ALL orphaned children deserve to be adopted, no matter what led them to become orphans. It breaks my heart when countries shut down and children are left behind to suffer (especially when it is part of governmental power plays)... We just narrowly managed to get our daughter home from Vietnam before that country shut down for several years.

You are totally right... the children absolutely end up the victims... I am praying for Guatemala and all of the children and families caught up in all of it.

You're doing a great job advocating!!
Hugs,
Erin
PermalinkPermalink 10/17/07 @ 15:27
Comment from: Lisa [Member] Email · http://guatemala.adoptionblogs.com
Thanks Erin. Thanks for your support - we need it.
Lisa S.
PermalinkPermalink 10/17/07 @ 20:27
Comment from: noelmountain1 [Member] Email
Our oldest son came from an orphanage in Guatemala--he is El Salvadorian and had been in the orphanage since he was @ 9 months old (after his birth mother had thrown him against a wall and he had suffered a subdural hematoma). We got him when he was 4 1/2 (the large bloodclot in his head had never been removed and he was suffering signs of increased intercranial pressure--in an adult it would have already killed him). He had surgery and is now doing great--still has some residual paralysis on his right side-and is developmentally delayed in some ways--but overall is fine.
What we discovered later is that the orphanages are so overcrowded--that older kids are turned out at about age 7 or 8 in some countries. We in the US cannot imagine an 8 yr old kid having to take care of themselves with no family to help them; espically one with medical problems. Unfortunately, this happens daily all around the world. The US government is not a friend to international adoption--they do everything they can to make the process as difficult as possible--and claim that it is to assure that the kids are safeguarded. I think it is more about $$$. There are lots of "true orphans" out there, but most are older kids and are not as desirable to adoptive parents. Both of our sons were older child adoptions. The most constant fear we have experienced was not from the county where the adoption was originating--but that our government would somehow mess the entire process up by refusing the return visa or citizen status (post 9/11 after INS became Homeland Security). There is no easy answer to the political problems--but there are still lots of kids out there that need forever homes. So tell anyone who is trying to adopt to hang in there and do not give up, the risks are there, but the rewards can be great! Cynthia
PermalinkPermalink 10/19/07 @ 05:20
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

Adopt Help Adopt Help Adopt Help

Misc

Subscribe to Transracial/Transcultural Adoption Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • Guest Users: 166