Adoption Network Law Center Adoption Network Law Center
Click Here to be helped in California!
Adoption Network Law Center
Adoption Network Law Center
Pregnant? Click Here
Adoption Network Law Center
Transracial/Transcultural Adoption Blog

12/18/06

Survivor- a game of race??- the conclusion

Posted by : Erin H in Transracial/Transcultural Adoption Blog at 01:37 pm , 620 words, 131 views  
Categories: Big Issues, The Media
Back in early September, I wrote this post about the new season of Survivor on CBS. Survivor producers decided that for its thirteenth season they would try something new, and start off the show with four “tribes” of castaways, divided by race. They had an Asian tribe, an African-American tribe, a Hispanic tribe and a Caucasian tribe.

After a lot of rambling in my earlier post, I concluded that I would have to “wait and see how it played out” before I made a judgment call.

Last night the season ended, and Yul Kwon, a 35-year old from California, was the first ever Asian-American to win the one million dollar Survivor prize.

And not only did an Asian man win, but the other contestants rounding out the final five in the game with Kwon were an Asian woman, an African American woman, a Hispanic man and a Caucasian man. I thought it was great that the final group ended up being so diverse.

On the “reunion show” after the finale last night, Kwon was asked how he felt about the show beginning the way it did, with the contestants divided by race (after a week, the tribes were mixed up and combined into two tribes).

SPONSOR
http://www.adopthelp.com

Kwon admitted that when he heard how it was going to start, he felt that he had made a mistake getting involved and worried about stereotyping and other negative results, but at the end of the show, he was very pleased with how it ended up.

This Yahoo! article says, “For a game that began in racial controversy, it turned into a showcase for the nation's diversity, according to Kwon.”

Kwon also said on the show that he thought being the “Survivor” was a great way to combat the stereotypes that exist for Asians, and that he hoped it inspired young people to realize that they could achieve all sorts of things. Not only did Kwon show that Asian men could be leaders and highly athletic as well as intelligent, he also recently was announced to be one of the honorees on People Magazine’s “Sexiest Man Alive”.

Beyond having an Asian man win the big prize, the show had some other great results. Many of the “castaways” really bonded and worked well together, and the people that they aligned with had little to do with race. They showed that it was WHO someone is that mattered the most, and not what color they were. When the host, Jeff Probst, said something along those lines last night at the finale, he was met with a huge round of applause from the audience.

So, did Survivor’s ratings gimmick turn out to be a good thing? I think my final answer is yes. The contestants formed friendships and alliances based on each other’s personalities and actions, not their skin color. The castaways that were lazy or loud-mouthed were unpopular no matter what race they were, there were athletic members of all races and the final five had representatives from each of the original “race-based” tribes. And then of course, an Asian man, who might have been the last choice stereotypically to win an extremely competitive and physical game, took home the million bucks (with a Hispanic man being the runner up and winning a killer car!)

My kids enjoyed it, and on several occasions some of them pointed out that the tribes were made up a lot like our family. :)

I think that the points were made that there is no “dominant” race, that members of all races can work together and live together very successfully and that there is strength in diversity.

Did you watch? If you did, let me know what you think.



Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Jan Baker [Member] Email · http://birthparents.adoptionblogs.com/
We love the show and did watch. I believe that the ultimate conclusion - that we pick friends not based on their race or ethnicity was a good message. It was interesting how race quickly became a non-issue in the show.
PermalinkPermalink 12/18/06 @ 13:43
Comment from: hebbyhoo [Member] Email
Yes, I watched it. I thought it was great that an Asian-American won. And he looked to be such a humble man. This season seemed to have a better meaning than others. I was amazed when my kids pointed out that they brushed their teeth with sticks too and they carried firewood "like on TV!". Sad that these people survive for 39 days, but there are people in this world that it is a daily life.
PermalinkPermalink 12/18/06 @ 14:07
Comment from: Jupe [Member] Email · http://adoptee.adoptionblogs.com
Hi Hebbyhoo... Have you used those sticks for teeth (it's not any old stick... there are certain species)? They are brilliant and according to my Mom, who is a dental hygienist, sticks are now being imported from certain coutries in Africa into America and supported as a good tool for healthy gums ... Not so sad at all... I just like being able to walk around cleaning my teeth with no white foam around my mouth to scare the elderly and little children...

I didn't watch, but had heard of this tribe bit on the show... am really glad it turned out well... these days it is nice to have any healthy indicator in society, no matter how small...

PermalinkPermalink 12/18/06 @ 21:26
Comment from: wendybarron [Member] Email
We don't watch "Survivor," but happened to see the part of the finale 9we were flipping channels). Both Tim and I were ecstatic when Yul won. I was actually even teary, and I don't even know a thing about him or the show. It was just so great to see an Asian-American man win!
PermalinkPermalink 12/19/06 @ 23:35
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

Related Discussions

    AdoptHelp
    Want to Adopt?
    AdoptHelp
    AdoptHelp
    Pregnant?
    click here
    AdoptHelp

    Misc

    Subscribe to Transracial/Transcultural Adoption Blog

     Enter your email address:
     

     

    Who's Online?

    • Guest Users: 94