Ready for Adoption?
Adoption Network Law Center
Adoption Network Law Center
Want to Adopt? Click here.
Click here to be helped in California!
Adoption Network Law Center
Pregnant? Click here.
Adoption Network Law Center
Transracial/Transcultural Adoption Blog

08/07/07

Transracial Adoption Questions - Adult Adoptees

Posted by : Erin H in Transracial/Transcultural Adoption Blog at 08:29 am , 809 words, 127 views  
Categories: Adoptive Parenting
In my last few posts I have been answering transracial adoption questions posted by readers (I am jumping around a little so I it seems that I have "skipped" your question, I promise I will get to all of them. Also, still feel free to go leave a question too.)

This question is not an easy one:
What do you think is the biggest difference between adult adoptees who resent their transracial placement and those who embrace it? As parents, what is the best way to ensure the latter?


First off, since I am not an adoptee, I cannot truly offer advice on this topic other than the knowledge I have based on research, reading and the shared experiences of others. I do not want to put words in anyone's mouth or speak for a group of which I am not really a part of, or of things I have never personally experienced.

So keep in mind that these thoughts are coming from an adoptive mom, and not an adoptee.

SPONSOR

In the articles I have read, it seems that several factors can go into an adoptee growing up to feel resentment towards a transracial adoptive placement.

They seem to be:

- When the ethics of the placement are questionable. When there are thoughts of, "Did my mother really want me placed for adoption?" that can be extremely emotionally difficult on an adoptee.

- When very little or no information is available in regards to the child's placement. Not knowing anything at all about you background, history or birth family can be very emotionally challenging.

- When race is ignored in the adoptive home. I have heard over and over that adoptive families who claim to be "color blind" and ignore issues of race, culture and racism are not doing their children any favors.

- When the adoptee is the only non-white family member, and/or the adoptive family lives in an area of very little racial diversity. These situations can leave an adoptee feeling very isolated and alone.

I think that the best way for adoptive parents to go about things is for one, to insist on an ethical adoption. Every adoptee should be able to have the knowledge that they were either a true orphan, or that their birth parent(s) chose adoption for them for whatever reason.

The next thing I recommend is, whenever possible, to get as much information as you can about your child's early life and history. Sometimes because of the nature of the adoption program or your child's circumstances it is not possible to get many (any) details, but in many situations, adoptive parents are finding ways to fill in the gaps of their children's life stories. If you have the opportunity on your adoption trip to visit the place your child was abandoned, to visit people who cared for him at some point in his life, to visit the place he was born or had lived, or to best of all, meet members of his birth family, I strongly encourage you to make the most of that opportunity. The information will be priceless to your child.

The third thing I recommend to adoptive parents is to not minimize the importance of race and culture. Although your child may not have much interest in race or culture at different times in his life, you should have aspects of your child's culture available and incorporated into your family's life, to show your child that you think it is important and something to be proud of.

I also recommend that transracial adoptive families live as integrated lives as possible. Find opportunities to go to church and send your kids to school where they will not be the racial minority. Although adopting more than one child is not possible for every family, I also encourage families adopting transracially to at least strongly consider adopting more than one child.

Overall, it is important for adoptive parents to teach their children about where they are from and to be proud of their roots. Adoptees should know that they are able to talk about adoption, race and culture any time and that they are not alone.

There is no magic formula to ensure that an adoptee (or any child for that matter) will grow up to be happy and well-adjusted, but there is a lot of information out there for transracial adoptive parents to help us do the very best job possible. Having open lines of conversation, sharing as much information as possible, incorporating culture into family life, acknowledging racial differences and issues, and supplying oodles of unconditional love is a really good starting place.


Here are some other posts I have written on articles about or by adult adoptees:

Transracial Adoption on NPR

Great Essay Written by Transracial Adoptee

Adoptees Feeling Like Outsiders

Lessons in Transracial Adoptive Parenting

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Shell [Member] Email
"There is no magic formula to ensure that an adoptee (or any child for that matter) will grow up to be happy and well-adjusted"

I'm not sure what this means...what is a happy well-adjusted adoptee? How does one measure this outcome?
PermalinkPermalink 08/08/07 @ 04:44
Comment from: Erin H [Member] Email · http://transracial.adoptionblogs.com/
Maybe I didn't phrase that as well as I could... I was referring back to the original question, about how can adoptive parents best assure that their transracially adopted child will grow up to be content with their life rather than resentful, and I was saying that there is no guarantee or "magic formula" for parents to follow.

I guess the only person who can really judge if someone (adoptee or not) is happy in life is that person. As a parent, that is what I want for all of my children... to grow up and consider themselves happy in life.
PermalinkPermalink 08/08/07 @ 13:09
Comment from: Shell [Member] Email
I'm not sure it's a fair question. Can people not be happy then resentful, then happy, then angry, then happy....why is it all or none?

Again, can you give an example of what a content transracial adoptee would be? And of course the opposite, what would a discontented or resentful TRA look like?
PermalinkPermalink 08/08/07 @ 16:13
Comment from: Erin H [Member] Email · http://transracial.adoptionblogs.com/
No, I am not going to get into stereotyping people and trying to generalize how adoptees are or are not. I also wouldn't generalize or stereotype adoptive parents... no two people are the same, and how one person acts or feels is going to be different than others.

Obviously everyone has times when they are happy, angry, and back and forth... I don't know anyone who is happy all the time or angry all the time. But I do think that overall, people tend to be either content in life or not, and obviously most parents definitely want their kids to grow up and be happy in life.
PermalinkPermalink 08/08/07 @ 20:46
Comment from: Shell [Member] Email
Okay, Erin....but you wrote well-adjusted adoptee and resentful adoptee - since you wrote it, and I was adopted...I'm curious about how you would explain what the two terms mean in the context of being adopted and how you arrived at this assessment.



PermalinkPermalink 08/09/07 @ 05:05
Comment from: AdoptionBlogs Editor [Member] Email · http://editor.adoptionblogs.com
Shell -
First of all, I believe Erin was using the terms "well adjusted" and "resentful" for their commonly accepted meanings and quite innocently so.

Secondly, if you are taking offense to this blog then perhaps it is time to consider why.

Obviously, you feel you have an axe to grind with Erin over this and I'm very sorry for that but baiting and fighting on our blogs will not be tolerated.

PermalinkPermalink 08/09/07 @ 07:59
Comment from: Shell [Member] Email
Lisa,

These terms are commonly accepted meanings? By whom? Adoptees?

I've never heard an adoptee describe her or himself as well-adjusted or not well-adjusted. So, there's no axe to grind, not at all...I'm simply curious about what Erin meant by well-adjusted and resentful. How does one dertimine if an adoptee is well-adjusted or resentful?

Erin wrote about a certain sect of the population to which I belong - I would think when something is written about me it would be perfectly okay to question it.

Perhaps I didn't explain myself properly.

PermalinkPermalink 08/09/07 @ 13:44
Comment from: AdoptionBlogs Editor [Member] Email · http://editor.adoptionblogs.com
Perhaps you didn't, or perhaps I simply am not understanding your questions as I should because they seem unnecessarily argumentative to me.

Erin isn't judging you or any sect of the population. Pardon me for saying so, but it looks like you're trying to pick a fight here and we're just not going to do that.
PermalinkPermalink 08/09/07 @ 22:57
Comment from: Erin H [Member] Email · http://transracial.adoptionblogs.com/
Shell,
If you reread the post, I never described adoptees as having to be either
"well adjusted" or "resentful".

The only time I used the word resentful was in this sentence, "In the articles I have read, it seems that several factors can go into an adoptee growing up to feel resentment towards a transracial adoptive placement."

The only time I used the term "well adjusted" was in this sentence, "There is no magic formula to ensure that an adoptee (or any child for that matter) will grow up to be happy and well-adjusted, but there is a lot of information out there for transracial adoptive parents to help us do the very best job possible."

This post was written to try and give advice to parents adopting
transracially. It was not written to classify adoptees, label their feelings or stereotype them in any way. In fact, as I said at the very beginning of the post, "First off, since I am not an adoptee, I cannot truly offer advice on this topic other than the knowledge I have based on research, reading and
the shared experiences of others. I do not want to put words in anyone's
mouth or speak for a group of which I am not really a part of, or of things
I have never personally experienced. So keep in mind that these thoughts are coming from an adoptive mom, and not an adoptee."

As I said in my reply to you, it is not my job to determine if an adoptee or anyone else is "resentful" or "well-adjusted". I would say if someone feels that they are happy and well-adjusted, then they are. I did not have any secret meanings implied to the words... I meant the standard, accepted, commonly used meanings.

You say that you never heard of an adoptee describing himself or herself as "resentful", well, here is an article that does... http://www.antiracistparent.com/2007/08/08/10-dos-and-donts-for-transracially-adoptive-parents/

There are many blogs, articles, websites, etc. where adoptees write about their experiences, and many share feelings of anger, resentment, etc. towards being transracially adopted. The original question by a reader was what kind of things can adoptive parents do to try and help their children
embrace their adoption instead of being resentful of it as adults. I was offering advice to try and help adoptive parents do the best they can in raising transracially adopted children. The post was not writing about you or about adoptees, it was written as advice to adoptive parents.

I am grateful to the adoptees that read my blog and offer advice to adoptive parents, and hope that adult adoptees and adoptive parents can work together for the benefit of adopted children.

Best,
Erin
PermalinkPermalink 08/09/07 @ 23:21
Comment from: Shell [Member] Email
Erin,

Here's an example of what I mean:

I would say I resent the system of adoption, well, a bit more than resent it - because it took me from my mother, father, family and people. It changed my identity and I did not see my mother or brothers and sisters for 32 years after being taken from her. I resent the system that did this to her, my father, my siblings and me. I would never say that I embraced my adoption. There was too much loss and confusion to embrace it.

Does this loss make me a well-adjusted or mal-adjusted person? No. I am a human being who was thrown into the system of adoption. I live with that - I cope with that.

Do I resent this and the fact that it is still happening to so many mothers, their sons and daughters and families? Yes.

So, what I was wondering about your post is when you say that you hope adoptees will be well-adjusted and can embrace their adoption - what exactly does that mean? That they don't feel bad about losing their mother, father, family, identity, culture and homeland? Or the degree in which they will cope with these losses? What exactly does well-adjusted look like ( your view)?

Does it mean that they don't search, that they search and are fine? They have no abandonment issues that stem from losing their family? That they don't question their adoptive identity? I am not trying to pick a fight, I am trying to understand what a well-adjusted adoptee means.

PermalinkPermalink 08/10/07 @ 05:07
Comment from: Shell [Member] Email
Erin wrote: You say that you never heard of an adoptee describing himself or herself as "resentful", well, here is an article that does... http://www.antiracistparent.com/2007/08/08/10-dos-and-donts-for-transracially-adoptive-parents/

No, what I wrote was that I've never heard an adoptee describe her/himself as well-adjusted or not well-adjusted.

I've heard many adoptees say they resent adoption and being adopted - that they resent losing their their mother, father, family and identity to the system of adoption. Usually this is post-reunion when they learn what really happened, or their mother and/or father had died.

PermalinkPermalink 08/10/07 @ 05:15
Comment from: Erin H [Member] Email · http://transracial.adoptionblogs.com/


I am not going to try and define "my view" of "well-adjusted" in a few short sentences in a blog comment, as like I have said over and over, what is happy and well-adjusted varies hugely from person to person, and the only person qualified to determine if he or she is happy in life, is that person. Not me. I don't have a "what it looks like" in my head... it can look like countless possibilities.

I expect all of my kids to have some level of abandonment issues and identity issues and I will encourage any that wish to search.

I hope that as my kids grow they will continue to love and embrace us as their family (or at least one of their families), as well as their birth families if they choose to reconnect with them.

I am very sorry for the losses you have faced in life and that you were taken from your mother. That is not "adoption" that anyone should support. If you read my post, that is exactly the type of situation I am encouraging adoptive parents to avoid... as I said, all adopted children should be able to know that they were either a true orphan or that their first parents chose adoption for them.

PermalinkPermalink 08/10/07 @ 06:49

Comments are closed for this post.

Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

Adopt Help Adopt Help Adopt Help

Misc

Subscribe to Transracial/Transcultural Adoption Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • Guest Users: 156