Click Here to be helped in California!


Pregnant? Click Here
Transracial/Transcultural Adoption Blog

05/01/06

What kids gain in adoption

Posted by : Erin H in Transracial/Transcultural Adoption Blog at 05:32 am , 605 words, 118 views  
Categories: General Adoption Issues, Adoptive Parenting, The Blessings
Sometimes I get tired of hearing about all that kids “lose” in adoption. Of course we all know that children who have been adopted have lost their birth parents, their extended birth families and sometimes their birth countries, birth cultures, etc. I would never discount these losses, ignore them or sweep them under the proverbial rug.

And yet I think sometimes people get so caught up in focusing on all the loss, that they forget how much good comes out of adoption too. I look at my son from Ethiopia. He was an orphan of the true sense, with both of his parents deceased. International adoption may have taken him away from his home country and culture and all that was familiar to him, and yet what was the alternative for him? Leave him in an orphanage in Africa? What would his life have been? What would have been his future? Now he has a safe and secure home, the promise of an education, all the medical care he will ever need and most importantly, a loving family that will love him and cherish him always.

SPONSOR

Look at my two older girls. They were relinquished to us directly from their birth mother, who was extremely abusive and neglectful to them. Foster care was in their future if an adoptive family was not found. Yes, they had to leave the only family they knew, their friends, their school and their lives. And yet, what was their alternative? Leave them in an abusive home? Let them be put into foster care where they would be among countless other older African American siblings hoping to find a home? What would their lives have been like? What would have been their future? Now they live in a safe and secure home, where we don’t hurt, neglect or belittle our children. They are truly loved and adored, and are thriving in school, all sorts of activities and are overall blossoming with a newfound self-confidence that I attribute to unconditional love, security in the home and a real sense of family.

I could go on with examples of my other children as well, but I think you get the idea.

Yes, my children will have to deal with issues related to being adopted, and issues related to being raised in a transracial family. But when you think about what their alternatives were, and what issues they would be dealing with in their first lives, I think it is a pretty good trade off.

I read somewhere that every adoptive parent should have the confidence and the knowledge that they are the best possible parent for their children. I know that to be true in my heart. In the world in which we live and the realities that exist in their lives, I am the best possible mom for them. Their lives are not perfect, but adoption has given my kids the very best chance of a positive future. I do not feel guilty that some of my kids are adopted, or that I am white and some of my children are black and Asian. They will grow up loved, educated, cared for, respected and taught to have pride in who they are and where they are from. They will be taught to be proud of the color of their skin, and yet not to judge others by the color of theirs. They will know unconditional love, and will see in this large multicultural family, that love does not distinguish between what color we are or how we came to be a family. I think more children should be so lucky.

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Susan [Member] Email · www.readingwritingliving.wordpress.com
Erin, I agree with you that adopted kids gain a LOT. But I do think there are many adoptive parents out there who actively perpetuate those losses - by denying kids connection with people from their culture, by insisting that they are "only Americans" now, etc. You are not one of those parents. I think you are doing a stellar job.

I also think that in spite of all the gains, adoptees experience loss and grief. It's not as if they are saying they would rather live in an abusive familiy or in an orphanage. It's that they wish these things hadn't happened in the first place. They wish they didn't have original parents who couldn't or wouldn't parent them. They wish their parents hadn't died.

I have two of the most incredibly loving adoptive parents anyone could hope for. And yet I still experience the grief and loss over my birthmother. (I did know her, too, for over 25 years) Most of the time we just live our lives and don't focus on these things.

What I do think is dangerous is when adoptees are told to feel "grateful" for the nice lives they have, and that it is of course so much better than what they would have had, had they not been adopted.

Your kids are still really young and probably have not spent a lot of time processing these things. Maybe they won't. But I hope that when they are adolescents and young adult and the full impact of what happened in their earlier lives hits them, that you will allow for the full range of their emotions and let them know it's okay to feel those losses.
PermalinkPermalink 05/01/06 @ 08:36
Comment from: Erin H [Member] Email · http://transracial.adoptionblogs.com/
Susan,
Like I started my post with, I would never discount or ignore the losses that my children have faced. In fact I would not discount or ignore any emotion that ANY of my children had in regards to any aspect of their lives.
Of course when they are older I expect them to have a lot to process (and we already do deal with a lot of that) and of course I will "allow" them the full range of their emotions.
The other thing I want to add is that I think everyone has aspects of their lives that they wish didn't happen, it is not only adoptees. My mother left my family when I was young. My dear friend has a father who was an alcoholic. Another friend lost a brother in a tragic accident when they were young. Another friend lost both of his parents at a young age. A kid I grew up with was horribly burned in a fire when he was three. Many, many people have things in their lives that they wish were different.

THe point I was making with this post is that when you do any research on adoption there is tons and tons of info on all that kids lose in adoption and all they have to grieve and and mourn and process, etc. and sometimes it is nice to step back and remember that there are good things that come of adoption too.
PermalinkPermalink 05/01/06 @ 09:08
Comment from: HeatherK [Member] Email
Most interesting blog and comments.
PermalinkPermalink 05/01/06 @ 15:26
Comment from: Enat [Member] Email
Erin, this may be only tangentially related to your blog, but I have a friend who was adopted at birth and he has told me that he doesn't understand the current push to pathologize the adoption experience. He says that it is expected that adoptees have issues and that, if you are adopted and don't have issues, you are accused to being in denial of your issues. He is of the same opinion as you, that we all have have circumstances in our lives that we wish could have been different but that we don't have to let these things rule our lives.

I agree that it is fatiguing to be constantly reminded of all that my son doesn't have by being in our family. Interestingly, though, no has mentioned any of those things about our daughter, an HIV+ teenager. It's like my son could have had so much more but my daughter, well, she should just be grateful for whatever she gets because, after all, what better could an HIV+ teenager expect? It's a very strange dichotomy.
PermalinkPermalink 05/01/06 @ 16:55
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

Misc

Subscribe to Transracial/Transcultural Adoption Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • Guest Users: 150